10 Sentimental Graduation Gifts for Best Friend Ideas They’ll Actually Cry Over
Graduation hits differently when it’s your best friend walking across that stage. Whether it’s a high school, college, or masters graduation, you’re not just celebrating a diploma—you’re celebrating years of late-night talks, shared stress, inside jokes, and growing up together.
While writing this article, I found myself smiling at old photos and rereading messages from my own best friend. It reminded me that the most meaningful gifts were never the expensive ones—they were the simple, cute, sentimental graduation gifts that carried memories. That’s exactly what this list is about.
Below are sentimental graduation gifts for best friend ideas that feel personal, emotional, and thoughtful—many of them cheap, DIY, and perfect for any kind of grad present.
This post may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Please read our full disclosure here to find out more.
1. DIY Memory Jar Filled With Friendship Moments
This is one of my all-time favorite DIY sentimental graduation gifts. A memory jar is simple, affordable, and incredibly emotional.
Fill the jar with handwritten notes—favorite memories, reasons you’re proud of them, inside jokes, and messages for the future. You can even label notes like “Read when you miss home” or “Read on a hard day.”
This gift works beautifully for a high school girl heading to college or a college grad moving to a new city.
2. Customized Graduation Gift Basket Just for Them
A graduation gift basket is perfect if you want one present that holds many small emotional touches. The key is personalization.
Include items that reflect your friendship: snacks you both love, skincare for stressful days, printed photos, and a handwritten note. You can easily keep this cheap while making it feel luxurious.
This is a versatile grad present that works for college, masters, or high school graduations.
3. Handwritten Letter or “Open When” Notes
There’s something about handwritten words that hits straight to the heart. Writing a letter sharing how proud you are, how much they mean to you, and how your friendship has shaped your life can easily bring tears.
To level it up, create a bundle of “Open When” letters—open when you’re stressed, lonely, excited, or doubting yourself.
This is one of the most sentimental graduation gifts for best friend ideas because it keeps giving long after graduation day.
4. Personalized Jewelry With Meaning
Jewelry doesn’t have to be flashy to be meaningful. A simple necklace or bracelet engraved with initials, a graduation year, or a short phrase can become a lifelong keepsake.
This works especially well as a cute and simple graduation gift for a girl. Every time she wears it, she’ll think of you.
5. Photo Scrapbook or Mini Memory Album
Scrapbooks take effort, and that effort is exactly what makes them special. Gather photos from high school, college, trips, random hangouts, and big milestones.
While creating this section of the article, I remembered how emotional it felt flipping through old photos—proof that memories become more valuable with time.
Add captions, doodles, and personal notes to turn it into a true friendship archive.
Thoughtful Amazon Gift Picks to Complete Your Graduation Present
1. Fill-in-the-Blank Friendship Memory Book
This fill-in memory book is perfect if you love sentimental gifts but feel overwhelmed starting from scratch. It prompts you with thoughtful questions about your friendship, making it easy to create something deeply personal.
Why it’s perfect: Ideal for college and high school grads who are starting a new chapter but want to keep their roots close.
👉 Check this friendship memory book on Amazon and start creating a keepsake they’ll treasure forever.
2. Custom Initial Necklace for Graduation
A minimalist initial necklace makes a beautiful simple and cute grad present. It’s subtle, stylish, and full of meaning—especially when gifted by a best friend.
Why it’s perfect: Easy to wear daily and works for both college and masters graduates.
👉 Browse this personalized initial necklace on Amazon for a timeless graduation gift.
3. Decorative Memory Jar With LED Lights
This aesthetic memory jar adds a magical touch to your DIY notes. The LED lights make it perfect for dorm rooms or bedroom decor.
Why it’s perfect: Turns a cheap DIY gift into something visually stunning and emotional.
👉 Find this memory jar on Amazon and elevate your sentimental graduation gift.
6. Custom Illustration or Digital Portrait of You Both
A custom illustration is a modern yet sentimental gift idea. It can be printed and framed or used as a phone wallpaper.
This is especially meaningful for friends who don’t live near each other anymore—it becomes a visual reminder of your bond.
7. Graduation Time Capsule Gift
A time capsule is a creative and emotional idea. Fill it with notes, small objects, photos, and predictions about the future.
Set a date for when it should be opened—one year later, five years later, or at the next graduation milestone.
This works beautifully for masters grads who appreciate reflection and growth.
8. Matching Friendship Gifts With a Graduation Twist
Matching doesn’t mean childish—it means connected. Think keychains with coordinates, bracelets with graduation years, or matching hoodies.
This is a cute and meaningful way to stay connected after graduation.
9. “Letters for the Future” Book
Create a small book filled with letters for future moments—first job rejection, first big win, homesickness, or self-doubt.
This gift shows emotional intelligence and deep care, making it one of the most sentimental graduation gifts for best friend ideas on this list.
10. Framed Quote or Location Map With Meaning
A framed quote paired with the coordinates of where you met or graduated together is simple but powerful.
This is a great cheap yet thoughtful graduation present that works for any level of graduation.
Final Thoughts: Why Sentimental Gifts Matter Most
Graduation marks the end of one chapter and the beginning of another. When you give a sentimental graduation gift, you’re saying, “No matter where life takes us, this bond matters.”
Writing this article reminded me that the gifts we cry over aren’t about price—they’re about memories, effort, and love. Whether you choose a DIY gift, a basket, or a small keepsake, the best grad present is one that comes straight from the heart.
Your best friend deserves nothing less 💛