10 Whimsical Storybook Baby Shower Theme Party Favors Ideas to Make Your Party Unforgettable
There’s something incredibly magical about storybook-themed baby showers. Maybe it’s the nostalgia… maybe it’s the dreamy colors… maybe it’s the way classic tales make everyone feel like a kid again. When I started writing this article, I found myself smiling the entire time—partly because I’ve helped plan several baby showers with themes inspired by fairytales and children’s books, and each one has turned out unforgettable.
In this guide, I’m excited to share my best storybook baby shower theme party favors ideas—perfect for boys, girl, and unisex celebrations. These ideas are DIY-friendly, cheap, simple, easy, and incredibly charming. Whether you want bookish book marks, adorable thank-you gifts, personalized souvenirs, or creative goody bags, you’ll find inspiration here to make your event feel straight out of a fairytale.
This post may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Please read our full disclosure here to find out more.
Why Storybook-Themed Party Favors Are Always a Hit
One of the reasons I love storybook baby showers so much is how personal they feel. Books carry memories. They tell stories we grew up with, and they bring parents and guests together through shared nostalgia. This makes storybook-themed favors perfect for guest of all ages.
Better yet, most of these ideas work beautifully for boys, girl, and unisex themes—and you can easily personalize them with names, colors, or quotes. Many are also eco-friendly, DIY-friendly, and budget-friendly, which is a huge win if you’re planning a celebration without breaking the bank.
10 Whimsical Storybook Baby Shower Theme Party Favors Ideas
1. Personalized Storybook Bookmarks
If you’re looking for something beautiful, bookish, and budget-friendly, this is one of the easiest storybook baby shower theme party favors ideas you can do. Custom book marks can be printed on cardstock, laminated, or even decorated with small tassels.
You can personalize them with:
- Baby’s name
- A favorite quote from a children’s book
- Illustrations inspired by fairytales
- Colors matching your theme (pink, blue, neutral, etc.)
These are simple, unisex, and they look gorgeous tucked inside goody bags.
2. Mini Book Favors
There is nothing more adorable than gifting mini books—especially small classic tales or tiny board books. You can buy sets and split them up, making this option surprisingly cheap. These make meaningful souvenirs that guests will want to keep, whether the shower is themed for boys, girl, or unisex.
I once attended a baby shower where the host thrifted vintage mini books, wrapped them in lace ribbon, and added a handwritten thank-you tag. It was a simple idea—yet one of the most charming favors I’ve ever received.
3. DIY “Once Upon a Time” Candles
Candle favors are always elegant, but adding a storybook spin makes them even more magical. You can create DIY candles using soy wax and then decorate the jars with labels inspired by classic tales—think woodland, enchanted castle, clouds, or nursery themes.
These are easy to personalize and can be made in bulk for a low cost.
4. Storybook Goody Bags
One of the easiest ways to charm your guests is with curated goody bags filled with story-themed treats. These can be designed for boys, girl, or unisex groups—whatever fits your baby shower look.
You can fill them with:
- Fairytale stickers
- Mini crayons or coloring sheets
- Little treats like cookies or chocolates
- Tiny toys inspired by children’s books
- Personalized thank-you notes
This option makes it easy to mix DIY and purchased items, keeping things cheap while still looking special.
5. Fairytale Cookie Favors
Cookies shaped like books, crowns, woodland animals, or stars are always a crowd favorite. You can bake them yourself if you love DIY—or order them and simply add cute story-themed packaging. These treats are adorable, delicious, and absolutely Instagram-worthy.
My friend once made pink and blue “storybook cookies” shaped like open books—they were almost too cute to eat. Almost!
6. DIY Storybook Seed Packets
If you’re hosting a more natural or woodland-inspired storybook theme, seed packet favors are perfect. You can print your own covers that say things like:
- “Watch Baby’s Story Grow”
- “Once Upon a Sprout”
- “A New Chapter Begins”
These make eco-friendly, unisex thank you gifts and are extremely cheap to put together.
7. Vintage Book Page Wrapped Chocolates
This is one of the easiest yet most elegant storybook favor ideas. Wrap mini chocolates in pages from thrifted books (not rare ones!), or print faux vintage pages on kraft paper. Tie with twine or ribbon and you have stunning souvenirs that look expensive but cost very little.
They display beautifully on a dessert or favor table, especially if you're going for a rustic or shabby-chic storybook aesthetic.
8. Personalized Story Quote Keychains
These keychains feature quotes from classic tales—Winnie the Pooh, Peter Rabbit, Cinderella, etc. You can order them already made or create DIY versions using resin molds or acrylic blanks.
They’re unisex, lightweight, and timeless—perfect for guests of all ages.
9. Baby’s First Library Bookplates
Bookplates are decorative labels that guests can add to the books they gift the baby. Personalized bookplates say something like:
“This book belongs to…”
They’re bookish, adorable, and surprisingly affordable. They’re also extremely easy to slip into goody bags or attach to any gift.
10. DIY Fairytale Bath Salts or Soaps
End your shower on a spa-like note with DIY bath salts or handmade soaps. Add story-inspired scents such as lavender, milk & honey, or enchanted forest. Package them with whimsical labels featuring woodland creatures, crowns, or clouds.
This is one of the simplest and cheapest ways to create personalized, meaningful favors your guests will genuinely use.
My Favorite Amazon Finds for Storybook Baby Shower Favors
These three products have been lifesavers for me whenever I helped clients put together **storybook baby shower theme party favors ideas**. They’re affordable, high-quality, and perfect for DIY projects.
📘 1. Kraft Bookmark Blanks with Tassels (Amazon)
These blank bookmarks are PERFECT for creating your own personalized storybook-style favors. They’re sturdy, easy to decorate, and come with adorable tassels that instantly elevate the look.
- Great for DIY lovers
- Budget-friendly and customizable
- Perfect for unisex, boys, or girl themes
👉 Create charming bookish favors your guests will treasure!
Click here to check the price on Amazon
📚 2. Mini Classic Storybook Set (Amazon)
If you want favors that feel extra special, these mini storybooks are a hit every single time. They look vintage, feel premium, and are perfect for your fairytale aesthetic.
- Ready to use—no DIY required
- Great for thank-you bags
- Perfect for storybook or woodland themes
👉 Add instant magic to your baby shower with these adorable mini books!
See the mini book sets on Amazon
🎀 3. Pastel Organza Goody Bags (Amazon)
These goody bags are lightweight, dreamy, and perfect for packaging your fairytale favors. They come in soft pastels—pink, blue, lavender, or neutral—which makes them amazing for unisex themes.
- Super affordable
- Perfect size for candies, keychains, bookmarks, or soaps
- Instantly makes favors look polished
👉 Make your favors look magical in seconds!
Shop the organza bags on Amazon
Tips for Making Your Storybook Favors Extra Special
If you want your favors to truly stand out, focus on the details. Here are some simple ways to elevate your storybook baby shower theme party favors ideas:
- Add personalized name tags or quotes from children’s books
- Use matching colors across all your favors (pink, blue, mint, or neutrals)
- Incorporate small illustrations like stars, clouds, or woodland creatures
- Wrap everything beautifully—ribbons, lace, twine, or kraft paper go a long way
The trick is to stay consistent with your theme. Whether you're inspired by classic fairytales, whimsical woodland stories, or vintage nursery rhymes, make the entire experience feel like a magical chapter from a beloved book.
How to Display Your Storybook Favors Like a Pro
Presentation is EVERYTHING. A gorgeous display can instantly elevate even the simplest favors.
- Use stacks of books as risers
- Open a vintage book and place favors on top for a “storybook moment”
- Add florals, lace, or woodland props for extra magic
- Use framed quotes from children’s classics as decor
Trust me—guests LOVE taking photos of beautiful tables, and your favor display might just be the moment that goes viral on Pinterest.
Final Thoughts
Creating dreamy, meaningful storybook baby shower theme party favors ideas doesn’t have to be expensive or complicated. With a few simple materials, some creativity, and a touch of personalization, you can create favors that feel straight out of a magical fairytale.
Whether you're planning for boys, girl, or unisex, these ideas will help you put together thoughtful, whimsical, and unforgettable thank you gifts for guest. I hope these ideas inspire you—and if you try any of them, I would genuinely love to hear how they turned out.
Here’s to celebrating new beginnings… one magical story at a time. ✨