10 Thoughtful Gifts for Book Lovers That Aren’t Books – Creative Ideas They’ve Never Seen Before
As someone who has spent countless hours creating gift guides and exploring unique presents, I can honestly say that few things are more fun to research than gifts for book lovers. But here's the twist—what do you get a bookworm when you don’t want to give them another book? Yes, gifts for book lovers that aren’t books are a thing, and trust me, they can be just as special (and even more surprising!).
In fact, when I was working on this post, I thought back to the times I’ve gifted books… only to realize later they already owned them. That moment when your “perfect present” turns out to be a duplicate is the worst! So this guide is a celebration of creative ideas, DIY inspiration, and thoughtful Amazon finds that will delight any reader—without a single novel in sight.
Let’s jump into 10 thoughtful gifts for book lovers that aren’t books, including cute, aesthetic, handmade, fun, and even coffee-themed surprises for the reader in your life.
This post may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Please read our full disclosure here to find out more.
1. Book-Themed Candle Sets (For the Scent-Obsessed Reader)
There's something magical about curling up with a good book and a cozy candle. Add in a literary scent, and you’ve created an atmosphere your favorite reader will never want to leave.
From “Sherlock’s Study” to “Pemberley Garden,” book-inspired candles smell like the pages of a classic novel. They also make fantastic aesthetic decor in reading nooks.
DIY Tip: You can even try making your own soy candles with essential oils and mason jars for a more handmade and personal touch!
2. Book Lover’s Gift Basket (Customizable & Fun)
Gift baskets are an incredibly fun and flexible way to spoil someone who reads. Think beyond snacks—fill a cute tote or basket with:
- Tea or coffee sachets
- Cozy socks
- Reading light
- Literary bookmarks
- Chocolate
- Aesthetic journals
You can go big or small, theme it around a favorite genre, or even make one for kids who love reading. I once made a basket filled with everything needed for a "rainy day reading retreat" and it was the most appreciated gift of the season.
Pro tip: Check out your local craft store or Amazon for small containers and filler paper to give it a polished look.
3. Literary Coffee & Tea Blends (For Readers Who Love Coffee)
You haven’t lived until you’ve sipped on “Pride & Peppermint” tea or “Hobbit Roast.” Specialty coffee and tea brands now offer bookish blends that make sipping as much fun as reading.
Pair it with a mug or an insulated tumbler and you've got a reader’s dream.
Now, let’s take a little break and look at a few highly rated Amazon gift ideas that pair perfectly with the above gift themes.
Amazon Product Recommendations
1. You Nique Designs Highlords Candle 8 Oz - Bookish Candles
Why it's perfect: These womens and mens candle won’t sit on the shelf, these gift for book lovers will be used and appreciated. Share these soy candles for home scented with lavender & vanilla with your loved ones, and let them know that you are thinking of them!
Why they’ll love it: It sets the perfect mood for reading—whether it’s fantasy, mystery, or historical fiction.
Give the gift of literary atmosphere! Find it on Amazon here and make someone’s reading corner smell like their favorite novel.
2. Reading Journal: For the Love of Books, A Book Journal and Planner
Why it's perfect: This reading log lets readers track book titles, authors, ratings, and their own witty reviews. It’s both practical and fun.
Why they’ll love it: It's a creative and interactive way to reflect on their reads—and it’s super aesthetic on a shelf.
Encourage their inner critic with this cute reading companion. Grab it on Amazon here and help them remember every page-turner.
3. Book Lover’s Coffee Sampler Box – Medium Roast Variety Pack
Why it's perfect: This sampler includes 6 gourmet ground coffees, each inspired by a different literary classic. Names like “Brew & Prejudice” and “Moby Drip” add a humorous twist.
Why they’ll love it: Ideal for readers who love coffee and cozy vibes.
Brewing joy, one cup at a time. Shop the sampler box here on Amazon and make every chapter more caffeinated!
4. Handmade or DIY Bookmarks (Crafty & Cute)
You can never have too many bookmarks! From handmade leather pieces to pressed flower designs, there are endless creative ideas for readers of all ages.
I once crafted bookmarks using vintage sheet music and wax seals for a Jane Austen fan. The reaction? Priceless.
For kids: DIY bookmark kits are fun gifts and engaging activities all in one. Bonus: they’ll be excited to use their new creation in their next bedtime read.
5. Custom Bookish Art Prints
Help them decorate their reading space with beautiful literary artwork. Look for:
- Quote posters
- Minimalist character illustrations
- Vintage book cover reprints
- Personalized bookshelf name prints
These look great framed in a reading corner or office. It's a top pick for aesthetic lovers and a great Amazon or Etsy find.
Want a DIY route? Design and print your own with Canva or Procreate!
6. Cozy Bookworm Accessories
There's something comforting about slipping into a pair of fuzzy socks, throwing on a hoodie, and diving into a good book. Book-themed clothing and cozy accessories are adorable gift options.
Some ideas:
- “Just One More Chapter” socks
- Book dragon hoodies
- Literary scarves
- Pajama sets with classic covers
They’re cute, fun, and functional. I once received socks that say, “Shhh… I’m Reading.” I wore them so much, the lettering wore off!
7. Reading Journals or Book Trackers
Journals designed specifically for readers are trending. These aren’t your average notebooks—they include:
- TBR lists
- Star-rating systems
- Favorite quotes
- Genre trackers
- Year-end reading stats
It’s like Goodreads, but cuter and tactile. Ideal for organized readers, book club members, or anyone doing a “52 Books a Year” challenge.
You can find these on Amazon or Etsy—or go DIY and make one with a bullet journal!
8. DIY Book Nook Shelf Inserts
This might just be the most unique gift idea on this list. Book nooks are miniature, hand-crafted scenes that fit between books on a shelf. Think Diagon Alley, an enchanted forest, or a cozy bookshop.
They’re a literal window into another world—and bookworms LOVE that.
You can find DIY kits or pre-made ones online. It’s definitely a top creative gift that’ll wow them.
9. Audiobook or eBook Subscription
Don’t give a book—give access to hundreds! Perfect for multitaskers or commuters, audiobook subscriptions like:
- Audible
- Libro.fm
- Scribd
…let your favorite reader enjoy stories on the go. And the best part? These platforms often come with free trials, so it’s a budget-friendly gift too.
Pair this with a cute set of headphones or a cozy eye mask for the full reading experience.
10. Bookish Self-Care Kits
Combine comfort with literary charm by assembling a self-care set for readers. Items to include:
- Bath bomb shaped like a book
- Herbal tea sachets
- Sheet masks
- Candle
- Relaxing playlist QR code
- Book quote print
Perfect for moms, teens, or even kids who enjoy quiet time with a story.
DIY Tip: Package in a box with tissue paper, dried flowers, and handwritten notes.
BONUS: Quick Amazon Gift List for Last-Minute Shoppers
- Book-themed puzzle set
- Literary trivia card game
- “The Book Was Better” tote bag
- Glow-in-the-dark bookmarks
- Reading-themed enamel pins
Perfect for: Secret Santa, stocking stuffers, or adding a little extra to a gift basket.
Final Thoughts
Writing this post made me appreciate just how much the world of gifts for book lovers that aren’t books has grown. From handmade bookmarks to creative Amazon finds, there’s no shortage of fun, cute, and meaningful ways to show you understand and appreciate the readers in your life.
Whether you're making a DIY basket, ordering a reading journal, or gifting a coffee sampler, the key is this: show them you see their love for books, even if you're not handing them another novel.
So, which idea are you trying first? Let me know in the comments, or share your own best bookish gift ideas!